What Temperature to Cook Tilapia in Toaster Oven? (Explained)

If you’re looking for a simple and delicious way to cook tilapia, you’ve come to the right place. Cooking with a toaster oven is one of the quickest and most efficient ways to make a delicious meal without heating your kitchen.

The optimal temperature for cooking tilapia in a toaster oven is between 350°F (176°C) to 425°F (220°C). The temperature of your oven must be just right when cooking Tilapia in a toaster oven.

Fresh tilapia. Credit: canva

Take care when preheating your oven; if it’s too hot, set it lower than 400 degrees Fahrenheit so it won’t burn the outside before heating through the inside.

If it’s too cold, turn up the heat until it reaches 400 degrees Fahrenheit for optimal results every time!  

Baked tilapia. Credit: canva

How to Cook Tilapia in a Toaster Oven

Prepping the Fish

Tilapia is an easy-to-cook white fish readily available in most grocery stores.

  1. Before cooking it, season it with spices or herbs of your choice, such as garlic powder, turmeric, basil, or oregano. You can also add some lemon juice or butter for extra flavor.
  2. Use bread crumbs to give the fish a crispy outer crust.
  3. Once seasoned, you can wrap the fish in foil (optional) and place it on a baking sheet.
  4. When prepping the fish, ensure it is clean and dry before cooking it in your toaster oven.
Raw tilapia fillet marinated with lemon juice, herbs, and spices. Credit: canva

Cooking Directions

  1. Preheat your toaster oven to 425°F (220°C). Put an oven-safe baking sheet on top of the rack in your toaster oven.
  2. Place the prepped fish on top of the baking sheet. If you’ve wrapped it, leave a small hole in the foil for steam to come out.
  3. Cooking time will depend on how thick your fish pieces are — generally speaking, thinner fillets will take around 12-15 minutes, while thicker fillets may take up to 15-20 minutes.
  4. To check if the tilapia is done cooking, use a fork to flake open one piece gently – if it flakes easily and has an opaque white color throughout, then it’s ready! If not, keep cooking until the desired texture and color are achieved. 
  5. Once cooked thoroughly, remove from oven and serve with sides like roasted vegetables or potatoes for a complete meal!
  6. You can also add additional sauces like tartar sauce or salsa for extra flavor. Bon appetite! 
Check this video about easy toaster oven-baked tilapia


  • If you’re using a toaster oven with convection, reduce the temperature of your oven by 25°F (14°C) and adjust cooking times accordingly.
  • Use a meat thermometer to ensure the fish has reached the proper internal temperature.
  • Place a sheet of aluminum foil on the baking dish to prevent sticking.
  • Check the fish regularly to avoid overcooking.
  • Let the tilapia rest for a few minutes before serving. This will help to keep it juicy and flavorful.
Credit: canva

About Tilapia

Tilapia is a freshwater fish found in shallow streams, ponds, rivers, and lakes.

It’s an inexpensive and mild-flavored fish, the fourth most commonly consumed type of seafood in the United States.

Tilapia offers essential nutrients like protein and omega-3 fatty acids. It can be cooked in many different ways, including grilling, baking, or pan-frying.

Grilling tilapia requires only 15 minutes and can be done with simple seasonings like garlic, lemon juice, salt, and pepper.

Baked tilapia is easy to make with minimal ingredients and takes about 25 minutes to cook.

No matter how you prepare it, tilapia is a delicious and nutritious meal option for any night of the week.

Cooking Fish in Toaster Oven and Its Benefits

Cooking in Toaster Oven

Cooking fish in a toaster oven is an easy and convenient way to enjoy a healthy meal.

Toaster ovens are energy efficient, taking up less space than traditional ovens and using less energy to heat up.

They also allow you to quickly cook smaller portions, making them perfect for single-serve meals.

The Benefits

The benefits of cooking fish in a toaster oven are numerous. It is an energy-efficient way of cooking and preserves more nutrients than other methods, such as frying or boiling.

Additionally, because you can control how much oil is used when cooking with a toaster oven, you can ensure that your meal is healthier by avoiding excess fat and calories from added oils or butter.

Tilapia fish fillet. Credit: canva


Can you bake fish at 200 degrees?

Yes, you can bake fish at 200 degrees! This temperature range is ideal for larger and thicker fish, such as salmon.

Cooking salmon at lower temperatures allows the flavor to come through in the finished dish. You’ll want to ensure your oven is preheated, reaching a steady 200 degrees throughout cooking time. 

How long does it take to cook fish at 225 degrees?

Cooking fish at 225 degrees can be tricky because this low temperature doesn’t provide quick results. But if you’re patient, the results will be well worth it — crispy, flaky skin and tender, juicy meat! 

Depending on how thick the piece of fish is and what type you’re using (salmon, halibut, cod, etc.), the time it will take to cook a large fillet can range from 10-20 minutes. 

How long does it take to cook fish at 250 degrees?

Well, it depends on the type of fish you’re cooking and its thickness.

Generally speaking, if you’re cooking a white flesh fish (cod or tilapia) about 1/2 inch thick, it should take between 10 and 15 minutes to cook at 250 degrees. If your fish is thicker than an inch and a half, you’ll be looking at closer to 20-25 minutes.

Also, don’t forget that the thicker the fish is, the longer it will take to cook! If there’s skin on your piece of fish, add a few extra minutes as well – this helps ensure that everything cooks through evenly.

Which oven setting is best for fish?

When it comes to oven settings for cooking fish, my go-to is usually broiling. Broiling allows the heat to penetrate directly from above and below, creating a crispy and delicious crust on the outside while maintaining juicy, flaky goodness inside.

Plus, unlike other methods of cooking fish, such as sautéing or frying, it’s much healthier since you don’t have to use all that extra oil! 

Your Page:


What are some positive and negative reviews of the recipe?

One of the most helpful positive reviews for this recipe comes from hhazelwood07. They claim that it is the best fish they have ever had.

Although they didn’t provide specific measurements, they used extra virgin olive oil as the base and added old bay seasoning, garlic powder, seasoned salt, and dry parsley flakes. They brushed this mixture on their tilapia, placed a lemon slice on each fish, and squeezed fresh lemon juice on top. They then baked it covered at 350 degrees Fahrenheit for 25 minutes.

This reviewer received 1,728 helpful votes for their positive feedback.

On the other hand, a critical review from an anonymous user mentions that despite the recipe receiving 4 1/2 stars, they found the fish to be dry and lacking flavor. They followed the directions exactly, but they believed it didn’t turn out well and described it as an unsatisfactory combination. This reviewer received 19 helpful votes for their negative feedback.

What is the nutritional information per serving?

Nutritional information per serving of this recipe is as follows: – Calories: 172 – Total Fat: 4g – Saturated Fat: 2g – Cholesterol: 46mg – Sodium: 354mg – Total Carbohydrate: 7g – Dietary Fiber: 3g – Protein: 25g – Vitamin C: 61mg – Calcium: 81mg – Iron: 1mg – Potassium: 497mg

These values are based on a 2,000 calorie diet and may vary depending on individual calorie needs. It’s important to note that nutrient information may not be available for all ingredients used in the recipe.

Additionally, if you are following a specific dietary plan, it is advisable to consult with a doctor or registered dietitian before including this recipe in your consumption.

Who tested the recipe?

The recipe was tested by the Allrecipes Test Kitchen.

When was the recipe updated?

The recipe was last updated on March 8, 2023.

Was this article helpful?